How to Choose the Right Horseshoe
No single horseshoe suits every horse. The choice depends on hoof shape, the horse’s activity and the ground it moves over.
There is no single answer to which horseshoe is right: the choice always starts with the individual horse’s hooves, movement, activity and circumstances. A shoe that works well for one horse may not suit another, even if they do similar work.
If your horse has healthy hooves, moves comfortably and has previously done well in a particular type of shoe, continuing with a similar standard model may be reasonable. However, a change of shoe model or a change in the horse’s needs should usually be discussed with your farrier.
This guide explains what influences horseshoe choice, the types of shoes available and how to consider different options in practice. The aim is to help you understand the relevant factors and take part in discussions about the right shoes for your horse.
Contents
What affects horseshoe choice?
Several factors influence horseshoe choice, and one solution rarely suits every horse. What works well for one horse may not be right for another. It helps to understand the factors usually considered when discussing shoeing with your farrier.
Hoof shape and size
The hoof’s width, length, balance and shape are important when choosing a suitable shoe. Horseshoes vary in design, and the shoe needs to work with the hoof’s natural shape and the way it is trimmed.
The horse’s activity
Whether the horse is used for riding, training or competition, or goes barefoot for part of the year, also matters. The loads placed on the hooves vary with the work, its intensity and how often the horse is ridden.
Ground conditions and environment
The surfaces a horse moves over affect both wear and grip requirements. A horse spending a lot of time on gravel tracks, tarmac, firm arenas or muddy paddocks faces different conditions from one mainly moving on softer ground.
Movement and loading
The horse’s movement is another important consideration. Some horses wear their shoes unevenly, strike themselves, load certain parts of the hoof more heavily or have a movement pattern that suits some shoe designs better than others. Farriers therefore often assess the hoof and the horse’s movement together.
The need for grip, support or protection
Horseshoe designs offer different features. Some models are used to provide more grip, while others offer more support or protection. Different designs suit different circumstances rather than one type always being better than another.
Material and construction
Horseshoes come in several materials and designs, including steel, aluminium and synthetic materials. They differ in weight, stiffness, flexibility and how they interact with the ground. The choice of material can therefore influence how a shoe performs in practice.
Horseshoes are almost always chosen in consultation with a farrier, taking the individual horse’s needs into account. To understand more about how hoof function, loading and care influence shoe choice, read our guide to hoof care.
The way the hoof is shaped during trimming directly affects shoe fit. Tools such as hoof rasps play an important role in this process. To learn more, read our guide to hoof rasps: choosing and caring for your rasp.
Different types of horseshoes
There are many types of horseshoes, with differences in shape, material and design. Some are widely used in many situations, while others are designed for more specific needs.
Here we explain some of the most common types and their main characteristics.
Standard horseshoes
Standard horseshoes, usually made of steel, are the most widely used type. They are the familiar design many people associate with horseshoes and form the basis of much routine shoeing.
They come in several variations to suit the horse’s activity and the ground it moves over.
Browse all horseshoes and find the right shoe
Trotting shoes
Trotting shoes are designed for trotting horses and the demands of harness racing. They are often lighter and can influence the horse’s movement in more specific ways.
Different models are used according to the horse’s needs, the surface and its movement.
Glue-on shoes
Glue-on shoes are an alternative to traditional horseshoes, attached with adhesive rather than nails. They are used when there is a reason to avoid nailing into the hoof.
Examples include sensitive hooves or rehabilitation, although they are also used in other situations according to the horse’s needs.
Specialist horseshoes
Specialist horseshoes have more specific designs and are used where a standard shoe does not meet the horse’s needs. They may provide additional support or change the distribution of load.
Examples include bar shoes, such as heart bar and straight bar shoes, as well as other models with particular functions.
Browse all specialist horseshoes
Browse therapeutic shoeing products
Hoof boots: an alternative to horseshoes
Hoof boots are an alternative to traditional horseshoes and are not permanently attached to the hoof. They are fitted and removed as needed and used in different situations according to the horse’s activity.
They may complement shoeing or provide an alternative during periods when the horse is unshod.
How to choose the right horseshoe
- Measure hoof width and length carefully
- Consider the horse’s everyday activity
- Take the ground conditions into account
- Choose a model to suit hoof shape and individual needs
- Always consult your farrier if you are unsure
Accurate measurements are essential when choosing the right size. See our guide here: How do I measure to choose the right size?
When are different types of horseshoes used?
Different types of horseshoes suit different situations. The choice depends on the horse’s movement, the ground it moves over and its everyday activity. There is rarely one solution for every horse, so shoeing is tailored to the individual.
Standard shoes for everyday use and training
Standard horseshoes are used for many forms of riding and training. A standard model often works well for horses without specific requirements, particularly if they have worn the same type successfully before.
Trotting shoes for racing and training
Trotting shoes are used in harness racing, where movement and balance requirements can differ from those of riding horses. The choice of model may depend on the surface, speed and the horse’s movement during work.
Glue-on shoes for sensitive hooves or specific needs
Glue-on shoes are used when nailing into the hoof is best avoided, for example with sensitive or damaged hooves. They may also provide a temporary solution during rehabilitation or in other specific circumstances.
Specialist shoes for individual requirements
Specialist horseshoes are used when more individual considerations are needed. They may provide additional support, alter loading or adapt the shoeing to the way the hoof functions in motion.
Hoof boots as an alternative or additional option
Hoof boots may be used as an alternative to traditional shoeing or alongside it. Examples include riding, training or periods when the horse is unshod.
In practice, several factors are usually weighed together. Shoeing decisions are therefore normally discussed with a farrier, taking the horse’s needs and movement into account.
In some cases, the choice of horseshoe nails may also be influenced by the shoe’s use and the ground the horse moves over.
Toe clips, side clips and other features
Beyond the type of horseshoe, several design details affect how it fits on the hoof. One of the most common is the clip: a small projection drawn up from the shoe.
Clips help stabilise the shoe and reduce movement between shoe and hoof. They form part of the shoe’s design and are found on many different models.
Toe clips
A toe clip sits at the front of the shoe, centred over the toe. It is most commonly found on front shoes and helps stabilise the front of the shoe. Movement of the front hoof can tend to push the shoe backwards, and a toe clip can help hold it in position.
Side clips
Side clips sit on the sides of the shoe, usually further back than a toe clip. They are often used on hind shoes, where movement and loading differ from those of the front hooves.
Quarter clips
Quarter clips are a type of side clip with a slightly different position, often further back on the shoe. The difference can be small but affects how the shoe is stabilised and how it stays in place during movement.
Unclipped shoes
Horseshoes are also available without clips. These have a simpler design and are used in different shoeing applications according to the horse’s needs and circumstances.
Clip placement and variations
The use of clips varies. Toe clips are more common on front shoes, while side clips are often found on hind shoes, but this is not a fixed rule. Combinations also vary according to the shoe’s design and intended use.
Other design differences
Horseshoes also vary in thickness, width, shape and nail-hole placement. Even small design details can affect how the shoe works with the hoof and how it remains in place during movement.
The number of nail holes varies between models. Many shoes have around four or five nail holes on each side, while others have fewer or more, depending on their design and intended use.
There are also differences between fullered and plain-stamped shoes. A fullered shoe has a groove in which the nail heads sit, which can influence wear and contact with the ground. Plain-stamped shoes have no such groove and have a simpler design.
These details may seem small, but they form part of the overall design and can influence how the shoe works with the hoof in practice.
Common mistakes when choosing horseshoes
Choosing horseshoes involves several factors, and misunderstandings about what affects the result are common. Knowing some common mistakes can help you make more considered decisions and have a better discussion with your farrier.
Basing the choice on another horse
What works for one horse may not work for another. Differences in hoof shape, movement and activity mean that shoeing often needs to be tailored to the individual.
Focusing only on the type of shoe
It is easy to focus on the shoe model, but the result also depends on how it is fitted and how the hoof is trimmed. The quality of the work is an important part of the overall result.
Overlooking ground conditions and activity
Ground conditions and the horse’s everyday activity affect both wear and requirements. A solution that works in one situation may not give the same result in another.
Choosing out of habit rather than according to need
A shoe that has worked well for a horse before can be a useful starting point, but the same solution may not always remain suitable. Changes in training, ground conditions or hoof development can alter the horse’s needs over time.
Drawing conclusions without the whole picture
There is plenty of information available, but without seeing the whole picture it can be difficult to know what is relevant to an individual horse. That is why horseshoes are often chosen in consultation with a farrier.
Summary
No single horseshoe suits every horse. The choice starts with hoof shape, movement and everyday activity. Several factors are always considered together, which is why different solutions suit different situations.
A shoe that has worked well for a horse before is often a useful starting point. However, changes in training, ground conditions or hoof development can alter the horse’s needs over time.
Different shoe types, materials and designs have different properties, but their overall suitability determines how well they work in practice. Horseshoes are therefore usually chosen in discussion with a farrier, based on the individual horse’s circumstances.
Understanding the factors involved makes it easier to consider the options and make informed decisions about your horse’s hoof care.
Examples of different types of horseshoes
Here are some examples of horseshoes used according to the horse’s needs, activity and hoof condition.
Example products
Frequently asked questions about choosing horseshoes
For more questions and answers about hoof care and shoeing, visit our full FAQ here.
